Oregon Pinot Noir has been getting a lot of attention in recent years – the climate in Oregon is a lot like Burgundy, so maybe it’s not surprising that both American and French winemakers have come to Oregon’s Willamette Valley to try their hand at making great Pinot Noir. The results speak for themselves – this is a region and a wine worth exploring!
This should absolutely be a “blind” tasting! One of the beauties of Oregon Pinot is that it’s still fairly new to the world wine scene, and hasn’t been swept away by the price points of “cult” brands from California or France. So if all the wines are new, let your palate decide what’s best. Serve Oregon Pinots that range in price – may the best wine win!
- Castle Rock Willamette Valley Pinot Noir ($11)
- A to Z Oregon Pinot Noir ($16)
- O’Reilly’s Oregon Pinot Noir ($17)
- Elk Cove Willamette Valley Pinot Noir ($22)
- Evening Land Vineyards Oregon Pinot Noir ($25)
- Argyle Willamette Valley Pinot Noir ($30)
- Domaine Drouhin Willamette Valley Pinot Noir ($40)
Chances are your guests can’t name a single winery in Oregon, so don’t worry if your local wine merchant has a different selection than the wines we mention above. Pull together a selection of Oregon Pinot Noir ranging from $10-15 on the low end all the way up to one “big-ticket” wine costing $40 or more (just to see if it’s worth it).
We tried to pick wines, however, that have a talking point or two. Castle Rock is a widely available brand at a value price point. A to Z is well-priced and a Top Pick from our favorite West Coast wine merchant, who also considers O’Reilly’s to be one of Oregon’s great values. Elk Cove has been featured in wine critic Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate, while Evening Land was voted one of Wine and Spirits’ top 100 wineries of 2009. Argyle is a big name producer (if there is such a thing!) in Oregon, and Domaine Drouhin is the Oregon outpost of a famous (and fantastic) producer in Burgundy, Joseph Drouhin.
So what music do you pick for a tasting of classic, elegant wines from a hip, up and coming region? We’d go with Michael Buble, the young crooner reinventing the standards of the Sinatra era in a classic style for a new generation. Start with is self-titled album “Michael Buble” and then let the music keep going with his followup album “It’s Time.”
For a follow-up album along the same lines, go with Eva Cassidy’s “Live from Blues Alley.” It’s along the same lines, a modern but faithful reinterpretation of songbook standards, and one of her more upbeat albums. Finish off with the soundtrack from “The Commitments.”
There are a number of cheeses that go very well with Pinot Noir, but also a few that you should avoid. Oregonwines.com suggests pairing Pinot Noir with Camembert, Cheddar, Gouda and Colby Jack, among others. Those are also relatively easy to find. But be careful with blue cheese or goat’s cheese – the acids in those cheeses will not blend well with your Pinot.
If you want to make heavy apps, there may be no better wine than Pinot Noir to match up with just about any food. Smoked salmon, seared tuna loin, chicken or beef skewers, turkey meatballs… the sky’s the limit. The only type of food not ideally suited to Pinot would be sweeter foods like desserts.
As with any “blind” tasting, disguise the bottles before you display them. If you have wine party decorative cloth bags, great; but paper bags or even aluminum foil work fine too. Number them in some way and then place them around the room to create a flow of traffic for your party. Have a simple scoring sheet where guests can write their comments (“cranberry flavors,” “smoky and smooth,” “thin and watery,” “tastes expensive!”) and rate the wines on a 1-5 or 1-10 scale. When everyone’s tried all the wines, collect and quickly tabulate the scores. Unveil the wines one by one, making sure to first highlight wines that some of your guests loved (or hated!). The great thing is, no matter which wine one likes best, everyone’s a winner. If you pick the $10 wine, congratulations – you’re a cheap date and can buy a case or two of your favorite wine for what it takes to buy a bottle of the others at the tasting! If you preferred the $40 Domaine Drouhin, congratulations – you have a sophisticated palate and are well on your way to becoming a certified wine snob!
Oregon’s Willamette Valley is located at the same latitude as France’s Burgundy region, which is known for producing the best (amd most expensive!) Pinot Noir in the world. Pinot Noir reportedly made its first appearance in Oregon when David Lett of Eyrie Vineyards planted the grape there in 1965. He was followed by a number of other growers in the 1970s but burst onto the world wine scene when his wines placed in the top three in wine competitions held in France in 1979 and 1980. The second of these had been arranged by Burgundian stalwart Robert Drouhin, who was sufficiently impressed with the clear potential of Oregon Pinot that he ultimately bought land in the Willamette Valley and opened Domaine Drouhin in 1989. Drouhin wines have been highly praised and respected for years in Burgundy, so the launch of Domaine Drouhin was a serious endorsement of the quality of Oregon Pinot.
Oregon now makes more Pinot Noir than any other U.S. state except California. There has been a resurgence in the popularity of Pinot Noir in the last decade, fueled in part by the popularity of the movie Sideways, the 2004 tale of two buddies who escape to California wine country before one of them walks down the aisle. The main character Miles is a Pinot Noir lover, and his hilarious exclamation “I am NOT drinking any [bleeping] Merlot!” sent shockwaves through the wine world. Suddenly wine novices everywhere were leaving their old standby Merlot on the shelf at the wine store and discovering what all the fuss was about with Pinot Noir. While Sideways proved a huge boon for The Santa Ynez wine region where the movie was filmed, Oregon too has been a huge beneficiary of the public’s newfound curiosity for Pinot Noir.